For the past few weeks, many of my colleagues and friends have been discussing and debating the illegal immigration issue confronting America.
Just like them, I too have been taking a great deal of time to weigh all sides of the issues. Tonight, I read an OP-ED piece written by the very man who helped give me the confidence to pursue a career in public life and education.
That man is the Democratic Congressman from the 16th District of Texas: Silvestre Reyes. Here is his piece. It helped me a great deal with my own opinions. Enjoy the article.
Our nation's immigration policies, as well as federal proposals for immigration reform, such as H.R. 4437, have recently been the source of much outrage and concern here in El Paso.
I served for 26 1/2years in the U.S. Border Patrol, and saw firsthand the hypocrisy and failures of our nation's immigration policies, and have long advocated comprehensive immigration reform in Congress.
As the only member of Congress with a background in border control, I have worked during my nearly 10 years in Congress to educate my colleagues about the fact that our current policies not only do little to honor our legacy as a nation of immigrants, they also threaten our security.
Unfortunately, passage late last year in the House of Representatives of H.R. 4437, the so-called Border Protection, Antiterrorism and Illegal Immigration Control Act of 2005, did not move us closer to the comprehensive overhaul this nation so desperately needs.
It did, however, illustrate that the majority of members of the House of Representatives either have no idea what Congress really needs to do to help keep Americans safe, or are more interested in scoring political points with the voters back home.
For instance, I offered an alternative proposal to H.R. 4437 on behalf of House Democrats that, unlike H.R. 4437, would have fulfilled and even surpassed the requirements of the bipartisan 9/11 Commission with respect to increases in personnel and equipment necessary to apprehend, process and deport undocumented immigrants.
However, none of the 219 Republicans voting supported my measure.
The realities of immigration reform and border enforcement demand far more than proposals for constructing impractical multibillion-dollar border fences, making criminals out of clergy or aid workers who render basic humanitarian assistance to the undocumented, or making the estimated 11 million undocumented immigrants felons.
We need a comprehensive immigration reform plan with three main components: strengthened border security; tough, strictly enforced sanctions against employers who hire undocumented immigrants; and a guest-worker program that offers a path to earned legalization for those who are willing to work hard, pay taxes and participate as productive members of our society.
The bill that was reported out of the Senate Judiciary Committee and is currently pending in the Senate is a good-faith effort at fulfilling those three imperatives. For instance, the bill includes a provision allowing immigrants who have been living, working and raising families in the United States to become full members of our society.
As a nation built by immigrants, we should welcome this next generation of immigrants who are seeking the American Dream. At the same time, by bringing the vast majority of the undocumented out of the shadows, law enforcement will be better able to identify the small handful of immigrants who are not here for legitimate reasons, but may instead pose a threat to our security.
Comprehensive, fair immigration reform is long overdue, and public outcry in El Paso and across the country has signaled that our patience is just about up. H.R. 4437 was unnecessarily mean-spirited and punitive, and did not address the fundamental failures of our immigration policies.
I was proud to lead the Democratic opposition to the bill, and find it encouraging that the Senate so far has been moving in a different direction. Enacting legislation similar to the bill reported out of the Senate Judiciary Committee would be a step in the right direction toward real border security and immigration reform.